Great expectations


I worked with an athlete who had one race in her mind for months.

She’d run the race a thousand times in her head. Every version went perfectly.

The race didn’t.

What struck me afterwards was how personally she took it. You might know the feeling. A result lands badly and somehow it feels like it’s gone against who you are.

That’s expectation at work. Chances are you’ve got your own version of it, you’ve just never called it that.

Expectation feels reasonable while you’re in it. It feels like caring about your work.
​
Look closer and there’s a contract underneath: if I do X, then Y has to happen. Y was never guaranteed. So when it doesn’t come, it feels personal.

There are two forms:

  • Expectation of outcome: this has to work.
  • Expectation of others: they have to approve.

Both do the same thing. They drag your attention off the process (which you can influence) and onto a result or a judgement (which you can’t).

That gap is where pressure comes from: the distance between what you can actually do and what you’ve decided has to happen.

Outcomes matter. But a single moment can only carry so much meaning, whether that’s a pitch, a hard conversation or a race. The moment it becomes a verdict on your worth, a standard into a sentence. Under that weight, people try harder but think worse.

The shift

This isn’t about lowering the bar. High performers need standards. What has to change is the deal.

Commit fully to the work. Stop demanding a particular result in return.

A better version of expectation goes something like this: do everything within your control, but let the rest stay uncertain. That takes more out of you than certainty does. But it keeps your attention on the next thing you can do something about.

Three reframes worth trying next time you feel it tightening:

From expectation to appreciation: instead of needing it to go well, notice that you get to do it at all. Doesn’t kill ambition. Just takes the entitlement out of it.

From expectation to experimentation: treat the high-stakes moment as an experiment. Ask "What can I learn here?" That moves you from threat to curiosity.

From expectation to dedication: attach the effort to something bigger than your ego. A teammate, a cause, a future version of you. Judgement is harder to fear when it’s stopped being about you in this moment.

I don’t think the aim is getting rid of expectation. It’s getting better ones.

Expect yourself to show up and stay present.
Expect yourself to act like the person you’re trying to become.
Let the outcome, the opinions and the timing sit outside of that.

This week, notice one place where you’ve signed a contract with an outcome you don’t control. What happens if you keep the standard but drop the clause?

Until next week,

Chris

The Mindset Matters Newsletter

Every Sunday morning, get actionable ideas and insights to redefine your limits and elevate your life.

Read more from The Mindset Matters Newsletter

On Thursday I spent the morning with twelve founders, talking through the biases I see most in high performers. Nobody's immune to any of them. They're normal psychological responses, and each one served an evolutionary purpose. You can't switch them off, but you can learn to manage them. The one that got a lot of attention was perfectionism. For a founder it looks like one more process document or one more strategy day before anything gets handed over. Perfectionism starts with uncertainty....

A couple of weeks ago the clocks went back, and the evenings started closing in. You adapt to that without much thought. You dig out the warmer training kit, move your run to the morning and leave a bit earlier for work. The season changes and you change with it. What you’re working towards rarely gets the same review. We tend to treat purpose as one fixed thing you find once and keep for life. I’d suggest a smaller question. Instead of looking for your purpose in life, look for your purpose...

An NHL goalie gave one of the better descriptions of flow I’ve heard. Devin Cooley plays for the Calgary Flames. He went undrafted, spent years as a backup, and is now one of the form goalies in the NHL. After a win, he was asked what had changed: “When I start having too much fun, it takes me from an unconscious goalie to a conscious goalie, and my conscious brain is really bad at playing goalie.” A week later, he said he felt completely in control of his mind, and that whatever it threw at...